Are you looking for a fantastic alternative to bully sticks that will keep your dog happily chewing?
While bully sticks are a hit for many pups, it’s always a good idea to switch things up.
Whether your dog has dietary needs or you just want a longer-lasting, healthier chew, there are plenty of alternatives that offer variety and satisfaction.
From meaty chews to vegetarian treats, there’s something for every dog’s taste.
Table of Content |
What Are Bully Sticks?
Before jumping into the alternatives, let’s quickly cover the basics: what exactly are bully sticks?
They’re 100% beef muscle, specifically made from the pizzle (yes, the penis) of bulls or steers.
They’re typically dried or baked, offering a protein-rich, long-lasting chew that dogs adore.
Despite being natural, some pet parents seek alternatives. This may be due to health concerns, cost, or simply a desire for a new option.
Also consider reading, Yak Chews vs Bully Stick.
Why Consider an Alternative to Bully Sticks?
There are several reasons you might be looking for something other than bully sticks:
-
Health Concerns: Some dogs have beef allergies or sensitivities, making it tough for them to enjoy bully sticks without an upset stomach.
-
Smell: Bully sticks have a strong odor that some pet owners find off-putting. If you prefer chews with a milder scent or more appealing aromas, there are plenty of alternatives that both you and your dog might enjoy.
-
Sustainability: If environmental impact is on your mind, you may prefer to explore more sustainable chew options.
- Cost: Bully sticks can be pricey, especially if you have a large dog that can demolish one in no time.
Choosing the Best Chew: What to Look For
When it comes to picking the right chew for your dog, here are a few things to keep in mind:
-
Nutritional Value: Some chews offer more than just chewing fun—they pack in extra vitamins or healthy fats.
-
Suitability for Your Dog: Consider your dog’s size, breed, and age. What works for a small dog might not be the best fit for a large one.
- Longevity: If your pup’s a heavy chewer, durability is key. You want something that lasts, not something they’ll inhale in minutes.
Bully Stick Alternatives: Vegetarian Chews
When you think of dog chews, vegetarian options might not come to mind right away—but they should!
These picks are loaded with nutrition and still satisfy that natural chewing instinct without relying on meat.
1. Sweet Potato Chews
Sweet potato chews are a fabulous alternative for dogs who love something sweet yet chewy.
They’re low in fat, high in fiber, and packed with vitamins—making them a great option for dogs with sensitive stomachs or those on restricted diets.
Why Sweet Potato Chews?
Not only are they gentle on your dog’s digestive system, but they’re also bursting with beta-carotene and vitamins A and C.
These are excellent for supporting overall health, while the chewy texture keeps your dog entertained.
2. Carrot Sticks
If you’ve got some carrots in the fridge, you already have a simple, affordable, and nutritious dog chew!
Carrot sticks make a fantastic crunchy treat, supporting dental health and keeping calories in check.
Benefits of Carrot Sticks
Carrots are loaded with vitamin A, and their natural crunch helps scrape away plaque from your dog’s teeth.
While they won’t last as long as a hard chew, they’re a refreshing snack that’s both healthy and easy on the budget.
3. Yak Chews
Yak chews are a all-natural chew option that can hold their own against even the toughest chewers.
Made from yak and cow milk, these hard, durable chews provide hours of gnawing joy.
Why Choose Yak Chews?
Rich in protein and entirely free from preservatives, these chews are a natural, long-lasting alternative to rawhide.
They’re great for dogs who love to chew but need a meat-free option. Plus, their hard texture helps support dental health by reducing plaque buildup.
Meat-Based Chew Alternatives to Bully Sticks
For dogs that crave meaty flavors, there’s no shortage of bully stick alternatives. These picks not only deliver on taste but also offer additional health benefits, from joint support to better dental hygiene.
4. Collagen Sticks
Collagen sticks are quickly becoming a favorite alternative to bully sticks. Made from the inner layer of cow skin, they’re softer than rawhide but still provide a long-lasting chew.
Even better? Collagen supports your dog’s joint health and promotes a shiny coat.
Why Collagen Sticks?
These chews are both tasty and functional, making them a win-win for dogs with joint issues.
The collagen helps support mobility while offering a chewy texture that satisfies their natural chewing instinct.
5. Pig Ears
A timeless classic, pig ears have been a dog favorite for years. They’re crunchy, natural, and can keep your pup entertained for a good chunk of time.
Benefits of Pig Ears
While pig ears are high in fat, they’re fully digestible and great for your dog’s dental health.
Most dogs love their rich flavor, but because of the fat content, they’re best given as an occasional treat rather than a daily snack.
6. Beef Trachea
Beef trachea is a crunchy chew that’s also rich in glucosamine and chondroitin, which support joint health.
Plus, you can fill the hollow center with soft treats or peanut butter for an extra-special chew experience!
Why Beef Trachea?
These chews do double duty: they support joint health and help clean teeth, all while providing a delicious crunch.
They’re a great alternative to bully sticks, especially for dogs who need joint care.
7. Tendon Chews
Tendon chews, typically made from cows or buffalo, are another excellent choice.
They’re thinner than bully sticks but still provide plenty of chewing satisfaction, and they break down easily, making them a safe, digestible option.
Benefits of Tendon Chews
Packed with collagen and protein, tendon chews offer a healthy alternative that also promotes dental hygiene.
They’re lower in fat compared to other meat-based chews, making them a smarter option for dogs on a diet.
8. Chicken Feet
Chicken feet might sound unusual, but they’re a nutritious and tasty option for dogs.
Rich in glucosamine, they’re fantastic for supporting joint health, and their crunchy texture helps clean your dog’s teeth.
Why Chicken Feet?
If you’re looking for a rawhide substitute that packs a punch when it comes to joint support, chicken feet are an ideal option.
They’re low-calorie dog treats, easy to digest, and great for dogs that need an extra glucosamine boost.
9. Antlers
Antlers are some of the toughest and long-lasting bones out there. Naturally shed by deer or elk, they’re long-lasting and packed with minerals like calcium and phosphorus, which support bone and dental health. Here is a detailed comparison of elk antlers vs deer antlers.
Benefits of Antlers
Not only are antlers durable enough for even the most aggressive chewers, but they also help keep teeth clean and strong.
Unlike some hard chews, they don’t splinter, making them a safer option for long-lasting fun.
10. Fish Skins
Fish skins are a unique and highly nutritious treat. They’re crunchy, low in calories, and packed with Omega-3 fatty acids, which support a shiny coat and healthy skin.
Why Fish Skins?
As a hypoallergenic option, fish skins are great for dogs with food sensitivities. They provide a satisfying crunch without the heaviness of traditional meat-based chews, making them perfect for dogs that need to watch their weight.
Conclusion
There’s no shortage of bully stick alternatives for your dog to enjoy!
Whether you’re after a vegetarian option like sweet potato chews or a protein-packed choice like tendon chews, you’re sure to find a safe, healthy treat that’ll keep your pup happy and entertained.
Remember to choose the right chew based on your dog’s size, breed, and chewing habits—and always supervise them when trying out a new treat.
FAQs
Why do vets not like bully sticks?
While many dogs love bully sticks, some vets raise concerns about them. One reason is the high-calorie content—over time, they can contribute to weight gain if given too frequently.
According to Toe Grips, bully sticks can be contaminated with bacteria. Lastly, for dogs with sensitive stomachs or beef allergies, bully sticks can cause digestive issues.
What lasts longer than a bully stick?
If you’re looking for chews that are more long-lasting than bully sticks, try antlers or Yak chews.
These chews are known for their durability, making them perfect for dogs who are heavy chewers.
Elk antlers, in particular, are tough enough to provide hours of gnawing entertainment, while yak chews offer a firm, protein-packed option that’s long-lasting and satisfying.
What is the Bully stick alternative for a sensitive stomach?
For dogs with sensitive stomachs, fish skins or sweet potato chews are excellent alternatives to bully sticks.
Fish skins are light, crunchy, and packed with Omega-3 fatty acids, making them easy to digest while supporting coat health.
Sweet potato chews, on the other hand, are gentle on the digestive system and loaded with fiber, vitamins, and beta-carotene.
Do vegetarian chews help with dental health?
Yes, vegetarian chews can support dental health! Chews like carrot sticks and sweet potato chews have a firm texture that helps scrape away plaque and promote cleaner teeth.
While they might not be as effective as harder, meat-based options, they still offer valuable benefits for maintaining oral hygiene.
If your dog prefers a tougher chew, consider trying yak chews—they're not only durable but also promote dental health!
What’s the best option for a heavy chewer?
For heavy chewers, antlers and yak chews are top-tier options. Antlers are incredibly durable, lasting longer than most chews, and they’re packed with minerals that support bone health.
Yak chews are another solid choice—they’re tough but slightly softer than antlers, offering a long-lasting, meat-free alternative that keeps even the most aggressive chewers satisfied.